Home  ›  Science Center  ›  Horse Gut Microbiome, Behavior & Welfare Study
External supporting research Gut-brain axis & behavior Peer reviewed EXT-S02

Horse Gut Microbiome, Behavior & Welfare Study

Independent peer-reviewed research in 185 healthy sport horses found significant associations between fecal microbiome composition, equitation conditions and behavioral indicators of compromised welfare, supporting further investigation of the equine microbiota–gut–brain axis.

Original study title

Priming for welfare: gut microbiota is associated with equitation conditions and behavior in horse athletes

Microbiome Gut-brain axis Behavior Equine welfare Sport horses Stress Equitation
Study at a glance
Year 2020
Study type Prospective longitudinal observational cohort study
Sample 185 horses
Duration 8 months
Population Healthy sport horses representing multiple disciplines and performance levels
Publication Peer-reviewed journal article
EquiNectar tested? No
Peer reviewed Yes
Open access Yes
Relationship External supporting research
185
Healthy sport horses studied
>32%
Microbiota variation jointly associated with six selected host and environmental variables
24.2%
Microbiability estimate for oral stereotypies
16.2%
Microbiability estimate for locomotion stereotypies
Research question

What did the researchers want to understand?

How stable is the fecal microbiome of healthy sport horses over time, which environmental and host-related factors are associated with its variation, and are differences in microbial community composition associated with behavioral indicators of compromised welfare?

Researchers

Study authors

Núria Mach


INRAE
Université Paris-Saclay
AgroParisTech

Alice Ruet


INRAE
Institut Français du Cheval et de l’Équitation (IFCE)
CNRS
University of Tours

Allison Clark


Open University of Catalonia

David Bars-Cortina


University of Lleida

Yuliaxis Ramayo-Caldas


INRAE
Université Paris-Saclay
AgroParisTech
Institute for Research and Technology in Food and Agriculture (IRTA)

Elisa Crisci


INRAE
AgroParisTech
Université Paris-Saclay
North Carolina State University

Samuel Pennarun


INRAE

Sophie Dhorne-Pollet


INRAE
Université Paris-Saclay
AgroParisTech

Aline Foury


University of Bordeaux
INRAE

Marie-Pierre Moisan


University of Bordeaux
INRAE

Léa Lansade


INRAE
CNRS
Institut Français du Cheval et de l’Équitation (IFCE)
University of Tours
Research organizations

Research institutions

INRAE

National research institute
France

Université Paris-Saclay

University
France

AgroParisTech

Higher education and research institution
France

CNRS

National research organization
France

Institut Français du Cheval et de l’Équitation (IFCE)

National equine institute
France

University of Tours

University
France

Open University of Catalonia

University
Spain

University of Lleida

University
Spain

Institute for Research and Technology in Food and Agriculture (IRTA)

Research institute
Spain

North Carolina State University

University
United States

University of Bordeaux

University
France
Methodology

How the study was conducted

Study design

The study included 185 healthy sport horses recruited from a larger population of 376 horses housed at the French National Riding School in Saumur, France.

The cohort included multiple breeds, sexes, disciplines and performance levels. The mean age was approximately 10.5 years.

Fecal and blood samples were collected at two time points: October 2016 and June 2017, approximately eight months apart.

To be included, horses had remained in the same housing for at least six months before the study and throughout the study period. Horses were required to have no gastrointestinal disorder during the four months before sampling and no antibiotic or immune-modulating treatment during the preceding four months.

Microbiome data were analyzed alongside detailed environmental, equitation, behavioral and host-related measurements to identify variables associated with between-horse and within-horse microbial variation over time.

There was no nutritional or microbiome intervention; this was a longitudinal observational study.

What was measured

Fecal microbial communities were characterized at two time points using sequencing of the V3–V4 region of the bacterial 16S rRNA gene.

The sequencing generated more than 13 million high-quality reads and identified 15,154 filtered operational taxonomic units.

The researchers simultaneously examined 41 environmental and host-related variables. These included equitation specialty and discipline, diet, housing and bedding, age, sex, body condition, parasite status, fecal pH, fungal and protozoal loads, hematological measurements and behavioral indicators.

Behavioral observations included oral and locomotor stereotypies, unresponsiveness to the environment, hypervigilance and aggressiveness.

Statistical analyses were then used to determine which variables were associated with differences in microbial community composition and to estimate microbiability for selected host traits.

Study findings

Key results

• 185 healthy sport horses were followed over approximately eight months.

• Six selected host and environmental variables together accounted for more than 32% of variation in fecal microbiota beta-diversity.

• Equitation specialty accounted for 6.5% of microbial variation, discipline 5.79% and bedding type 5.2%.

• Hypervigilant behavior was associated with approximately 4.97% of microbiota variation.

• Oral stereotypies and aggressive behavior were associated with differences in the abundance of particular bacterial genera.

• Estimated microbiability was 24.2% for oral stereotypies and 16.2% for locomotor stereotypies.

• Estimated microbiability was 13% for aggressiveness and 9% for hypervigilance.

• 45 bacterial genera differed significantly between the two sampling points, demonstrating that even healthy horses' fecal microbiota changed substantially over time.

• The researchers identified a core microbiota of 29 genera shared across the cohort.

Interpretation

What do the findings mean?

This large longitudinal study provides evidence that the equine gut microbiome is associated with both the horse's environment and aspects of behavior and welfare.

Six selected environmental and host variables together accounted for more than 32% of variation in microbial community composition. Equitation specialty, discipline and bedding were among the strongest environmental associations, while hypervigilance was one of the behavioral factors associated with microbiome variation.

The estimated microbiability of oral stereotypies was 24.2% and locomotor stereotypies 16.2%. Aggressiveness and hypervigilance showed lower estimates of 13% and 9% respectively.

These findings support the existence of an equine microbiota–gut–brain relationship, but its direction is unresolved. Stress and behavior may alter the gut environment; microbial activity may influence neural, endocrine or immune signaling; and both processes may occur simultaneously.

The study therefore strengthens the scientific case for investigating the gut as one component of whole-horse welfare rather than establishing the microbiome as a single cause of behavioral problems.

In practice

Why this research matters

Sport horses experience combinations of physical training, housing, diet, social environment and mental demands. This study shows that these factors are associated with measurable differences in the gut microbial community.

Equitation specialty, discipline and bedding type were among the environmental variables most strongly associated with microbiota composition. Hypervigilance was also independently associated with microbial variation.

Behavioral indicators including oral and locomotor stereotypies and aggressiveness were associated with differences in particular bacterial groups.

The findings reinforce the idea that equine digestive biology should not necessarily be considered in isolation from management, stress, behavior and welfare. However, because the study was observational, it cannot establish whether microbial differences influenced behavior, behavior and stress altered the microbiome, or both occurred together.

Research transparency

Study limitations

This was an observational study and did not manipulate the microbiome or randomly assign horses to different treatments. Associations between microbial composition and behavior therefore cannot establish cause and effect.

The horses were drawn from a single large institution, the French National Riding School in Saumur. Although the cohort included several disciplines and performance levels, the findings may not generalize directly to all horse populations or management systems.

Microbiome measurements were based on fecal samples. Fecal microbial communities provide a practical measure of the distal gastrointestinal environment but are not identical to microbial communities within every region of the cecum and colon.

Samples were collected at two time points approximately eight months apart. This demonstrated substantial temporal variation but cannot describe shorter-term fluctuations between those sampling dates.

Behavioral observations and microbiome composition may both be influenced by common environmental variables, including training, management and housing.

Microbiability estimates describe statistical covariance between microbial composition and phenotypic traits. They should not be interpreted as the percentage of a behavior directly caused by gut bacteria.

The study therefore provides strong evidence of association and an important basis for mechanistic research, but not evidence that manipulating the microbiome will necessarily alter behavior.

EquiNectar context

How this research relates to EquiNectar

This research did not test EquiNectar and was conducted independently of Tharos Ltd.

Its relevance is biological and mechanistic. In a large population of healthy sport horses, gut microbiome composition was associated with equitation conditions and with behavioral indicators including stereotypies, hypervigilance and aggressiveness.

This provides independent evidence that the equine microbiome is related not only to digestion but also to aspects of behavior, stress and welfare.

Published EquiNectar studies separately demonstrate that EquiNectar supplementation can be associated with measurable changes in the equine microbiome and metabolome. The present study helps explain why changes in the gut microbial environment may be scientifically interesting beyond digestive measurements alone.

However, this paper provides no evidence that EquiNectar alters behavior or improves welfare. That question would require direct intervention studies measuring both EquiNectar exposure and behavioral outcomes.

Tharos / EquiNectar involvement

None. This study was conducted independently of Tharos Ltd and EquiNectar. Neither EquiNectar nor any other Tharos product was evaluated in the research.

EquiNectar evaluated No
Transparency

Funding & competing interests

Funding statement

Production of the datasets used in the study was supported by grants from Fonds Éperon and the Institut Français du Cheval et de l’Équitation (IFCE). Yuliaxis Ramayo-Caldas was supported by the European Union Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation programme through Marie Skłodowska-Curie P-Sphere grant agreement 6655919. The authors state that the funding sources had no role in study design, data collection, analysis, or preparation and submission of the manuscript.

Source record

Publication details

Journal
Scientific Reports
Publisher
Springer Nature
Year
2020
Volume
10
Issue
1
Pages / article
8311
PMID
32433513
Species
Horse
Population
Healthy sport horses representing multiple disciplines and performance levels
Sample
185 horses
Duration
8 months
Setting
French National Riding School, Saumur, France
License
CC BY 4.0
Recommended citation

Mach N, Ruet A, Clark A, Bars-Cortina D, Ramayo-Caldas Y, Crisci E, Pennarun S, Dhorne-Pollet S, Foury A, Moisan MP, Lansade L. Priming for welfare: gut microbiota is associated with equitation conditions and behavior in horse athletes. Scientific Reports. 2020;10:8311. doi:10.1038/s41598-020-65444-9.